Updated November, 2026
This DIY paper cross is a smaller version of a vintage hymnal cross I made using pages from an old church hymnal. I originally created this mini version to teach at a craft workshop during an upcoming Women’s Retreat. After a little experimenting (and a cup of coffee!), I figured out the measurements and steps needed to make this pretty little paper cross.

Supplies for a DIY Paper Cross
Here’s what you’ll need to make this smaller vintage hymnal paper cross:
- 2 large popsicle sticks, glued together in a cross formation
- Pages from an old church hymnal, cut to the following sizes:
- 1 piece cut to 1/4 page
- 5 pieces cut to 1/8 page
- 8 pieces cut to 1/16 page
- 1 full page for the rosette center
- Glitter (optional)
Where to Find Vintage Hymnal and Sheet Music Pages
If you don’t have an old hymnal on hand, you can also purchase individual vintage hymnal pages or sheet music pages on Etsy. There are sellers offering individual pages, so you don’t necessarily need to buy an entire book. You can also look for old hymnals at church rummage sales, thrift stores and used bookstores.

How to Make Paper Cones from Hymnal Pages
The paper cones are the foundation of this mini hymnal cross. They’re simple to make once you get the hang of rolling and securing them. The photos below show the process using old map pages, but the same technique works just as well with vintage hymnal pages, sheet music, or old book pages.
Hold paper horizontally, with right hand holding upper right corner and left hand holding lower left corner.

Bring corners towards each other and overlap.

Hold the opening of the cone together with your right hand while pulling the paper tight with your left hand to make the cone shape. This will feel awkward at first but keep at it. Pretty soon you’ll be able to make them very quickly.

Run a strip of hot glue along the side of the cone to secure.

Once you’ve rolled 14 cones in the different sizes, you’re ready to assemble your cross.
How to Assemble the Mini Paper Hymnal Cross.

Before assembling your cross, glue a small hanger or magnet to the back. I used a few strands of burlap to create a simple hanger.

Start with the largest paper cone. Glue the largest cone (made from 1/4 of a hymnal page) to the bottom section of the popsicle stick cross. Extend it slightly beyond the stick to cover the wood.

Add the five medium cones. Using the cones made from 1/8-page pieces, glue two to each arm of the cross, one to the top, and two alongside the largest bottom cone. Allow the edges to extend beyond the popsicle sticks.

Fill in with the smaller cones. Use the eight cones made from 1/16-page pieces to fill the gaps and add texture and dimension. Place two along each side of the arms and top, and the remaining two over the cones at the bottom.

You will glue 2 on each side of the arms and the top. The remaining 2 cones get glued to the bottom of the cross, on top of the existing cones.
How to Make a Paper Rosette for the Cross
The paper rosette adds a pretty finishing touch to the center of the mini hymnal cross. I’ll be adding step-by-step instructions and photos for making the rosette soon, so you can create the entire cross from start to finish.

If you want to glitter it, “dip” the face of the rosette in some white glue and then dip it again in some glitter. Then glue the rosette to the center of your cross.
That is the science of how to make the mini hymnal cross. The “art” part comes when you do your own thing from here, adding more cones in more sizes until you achieve a look that pleases you!
Storing Your Paper Crafts
A little tip for preserving your paper creations: Paper crafts made with glue should be stored in a cool, dry place where temperatures and humidity remain relatively consistent. Avoid storing them in attics, basements, garages, or other areas subject to temperature extremes and moisture. These conditions can affect both the paper and the glue over time.
Make the Original Vintage Hymnal Cross
If you love this smaller version, you might also enjoy the original vintage hymnal paper cross I made for a women’s retreat. It’s a much larger version, measuring approximately 24 x 12 inches, and makes a beautiful piece of handmade wall decor. Here’s a link to that post: A Vintage Hymnal Paper Cross.
Discover more from The Home Spun Styling Co.
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


beautiful, just beautiful.