Updated November, 2026
Several years ago, we were getting ready for our annual Women’s Retreat at the Tuscarora Conference Center in Mount Bethel, Pennsylvania. Each year, we created a new focal point for our booth—something that would inspire creativity and generate excitement for the women as they arrived.
One Sunday, while everyone else was enjoying the Super Bowl, a warm fire, and nachos, I enjoyed working on a prototype for a large cross wall hanging made from old hymnal pages. I loved the idea of using the pages to create something with a little history, texture, and character, and that afternoon’s experiment turned into this vintage hymnal paper cross.

Making the Cardboard Cross Template
I started with a template cut from cardboard. I made it 24 inches long by 12 inches across.


Adding a Hanger to the Back of the Cross
Before adding the paper cones, make a hanging loop on the back of the cardboard cross. I used a piece of jute twine, formed into a loop, and secured the ends to the cardboard with hot glue. This way, the cross is ready to hang once all the paper cones are in place.shed cross would be ready to hang once assembled.
Making the Paper Cones
I made the paper cones from old hymnal pages in three different sizes: full page, half page, and quarter page. I like to see gradations in color so I used pages from two different hymnals. Over the years, we’ve tried several techniques for making these cones, but my favorite is the one I used for my DIY map wreath. You can follow the same rolling and securing technique for this cross. I used approximately 100 paper cones to make this cross. The exact number will vary depending on the size of your cardboard template, the size of your cones, and how full and layered you want your finished cross to look.

Arranging the Paper Cones on the Cross
Making a paper cross or wreath is as much art as it is science so each one will be different depending on how you choose to place the cones and how much layering you do. As a starting point, I placed 3 large cones on the top and arms of the cross.

Then I started layering on additional cones in a pattern that was pleasing to my eye and keeping in mind the need for symmetry.

After I had the top of the cross fairly filled in, I felt the need to work up from the bottom. Again I started by gluing on three large cones first and then worked my way up the cross.

The hardest part for me is knowing when to stop! The more cones you layer, the more texture and dimension the cross takes on. If you notice any bare spots, it’s easy to slip in another cone of the right size to fill the gap.


Storing Your Paper Crafts
A little tip for preserving your paper creations: Paper crafts made with glue should be stored in a cool, dry place where temperatures and humidity remain relatively consistent. Avoid storing them in attics, basements, garages, or other areas subject to temperature extremes and moisture. These conditions can affect both the paper and the glue over time.
Make a Mini Version of This Vintage Hymnal Cross
If you love the look of this large vintage hymnal cross but want to try a smaller version, I also created a mini paper cross using the same idea. It’s a fun project for Easter decorating or a craft workshop, and you can find the step-by-step instructions here: DIY Mini Vintage Hymnal Paper Cross.
Discover more from The Home Spun Styling Co.
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


Did you use anything to seal this with? I want to do something similar to this but I can’t figure out how to seal it to protect it from dust. What would you recommemd?
Hi Brittany. We didn’t seal our paper cross as we like how the paper ages naturally. Dust hasn’t been a problem. Debra
where did you print your sheets from?
Carrie – We pick up old hymnals that are falling apart at thrift stores and rummage sales and use the pages from them. Debra
Could not find ANYWHERE the item I needed to decorate a First Communion card box, but this is a FANTASTIC idea. I will try it and send you pics when I finish!! Thank you so very, very much for this unique concept. I will be using various shades of lavender paper…wish me luck!! Thank you again!
Can’t wait to see it!
did you ever do a smaller one? Thank you for such great pictures!
Yes we did! Here’s the link: https://homespunstyle.net/2015/02/11/mini-paper-hymnal-cross-diy/
Hi Brittanny, How many cones did it take to fill in your cross?
Hi Adrienne, I made this cross a few years ago so I can’t remember. The more layers you add, the more cones it will take. This cross was pretty full with a lot of depth so I am sure it was close to 100 cones. Hope this helps! Debra
Thank you! Getting my cones ready!
What kind of hanger did you use? It is beautiful.
Thank you Susan! The cross is very light so I was able to simply use a loop of burlap string and hot glue it onto the back of the cross. Happy Resurrection Day!
Were you able to get this down to a science and have it finished in 1 hour
Hi Beth, This large cross is a labor of love and takes many hours. The mini cross which is also on our blog can be done in less than an hour.
There is paper that can be purchased at craft stores or online, that looks like old yellowed parchment. I am planning on making this beautiful cross for my church using an old hymnal and copying the hymns onto this paper, which comes in different shades of ivory and beige. One year I decorated a tree for my church using this paper onto which I had copied pertinent Christmas hymns or Biblical passages relating to the Nativity and then cut into star shapes.. I then hung the stars on the tree which also had little starry lights.
Thanks for the tip Lida! I wasn’t aware of this. Have fun making a cross. Blessings, Debra
I was wanting to know, how wide is the cross arms for lack of a better word? I know the length and width of the whole cross but each arm is how wide?
The cardboard template was 15 inches across. The paper cones extended beyond about 1 1/2 inches on each “arm”.